Smith & Wesson 686-4 vs Smith & Wesson 686-5

Head to Head Comparison

Smith & Wesson 686-4
Critic Rating
98%
User Rating
97%
Smith & Wesson 686-5
Critic Rating
98%
User Rating
97%
50
Accuracy
50
10-50 yeards
Range
10-50 yeards
1 ft/sec
Recoil Velocity
1 ft/sec
10+1 rounds
Capacity
10+1 rounds
50
Mobility
50
50
Ergonomics
50
50
Fit & Finish
50
50
Reliabilty
50
MSRP: $558.34
Used Price: $558.34
New Price: $558.34
MSRP: $558.34
Used Price: $558.34
New Price: $558.34

Smith & Wesson 686-5 vs Smith & Wesson 686-4


Smith & Wesson is a renowned name in the world of firearms, known for its quality craftsmanship and reliable performance. Two of its popular revolver models, the 686-5 and the 686-4, often draw comparisons due to their similarities and differences. In this article, we'll delve into the intricacies of both models to help you understand which might better suit your needs.

Smith & Wesson 686-5 and Smith & Wesson 686-4


The Smith & Wesson 686 series is celebrated for its robust construction and smooth operation. The 686-5 and 686-4 are both part of this series, offering shooters a dependable platform for various applications.

History and Background


Both the 686-5 and 686-4 have their roots traced back to the original Smith & Wesson Model 19, a .357 Magnum revolver introduced in the mid-20th century. Over the years, these models have undergone several iterations, incorporating advancements in materials and design.

Features and Specifications


Smith & Wesson 686-5


Design and Construction


The 686-5 boasts a stainless steel frame and cylinder, providing durability and corrosion resistance. Its ergonomic grip ensures comfortable handling during extended shooting sessions.

Caliber and Capacity


Chambered in .357 Magnum/.38 Special, the 686-5 offers versatile ammunition options. It typically has a six-round capacity, suitable for both self-defense and target shooting.

Barrel Length and Weight


Available with barrel lengths ranging from 2.5 inches to 6 inches, the 686-5 caters to various preferences. Despite its solid build, it remains relatively lightweight, enhancing portability without compromising on stability.

Smith & Wesson 686-4


Design and Construction


Similar to its successor, the 686-4 features a stainless steel construction, ensuring longevity and resilience. Its classic design pays homage to traditional revolver aesthetics.

Caliber and Capacity


Like the 686-5, the 686-4 is chambered in .357 Magnum/.38 Special, offering compatibility with a wide range of ammunition. It typically holds six rounds in its cylinder, providing ample firepower.

Barrel Length and Weight


The 686-4 is available in various barrel lengths, catering to different shooting preferences. Despite its sturdy build, it remains well-balanced, facilitating accurate shooting.

Performance Comparison


Accuracy


Both the 686-5 and 686-4 are renowned for their exceptional accuracy, thanks to their solid construction and precise engineering. Shooters can consistently achieve tight groupings at various distances.

Recoil Management


With their robust frames and ergonomic grips, both models excel in managing recoil, allowing shooters to maintain control and stay on target for follow-up shots.

Reliability


Built to withstand rigorous use, the 686-5 and 686-4 demonstrate outstanding reliability, cycling smoothly without issues even under adverse conditions.

Price and Availability


The prices of the 686-5 and 686-4 may vary depending on factors such as barrel length and finish. However, both models offer excellent value for money considering their quality construction and performance.

User Experience and Reviews


Shooters praise the 686-5 and 686-4 for their superb ergonomics, smooth trigger pulls, and consistent accuracy. These positive attributes make them popular choices among both novice shooters and seasoned enthusiasts.

Conclusion


The Smith & Wesson 686-5 and 686-4 are formidable revolver options, offering exceptional performance and reliability. Whether you prioritize specific features or aesthetics, you can't go wrong with either choice.

FAQs


  1. 1. Which model is better for concealed carry, the 686-5, or the 686-4?
    • Both models can be suitable for concealed carry depending on individual preferences. The shorter barrel lengths of the 686-5 may offer better concealability, but some may prefer the classic aesthetics of the 686-4.
  2. 2. Are there any significant differences in trigger pull between the 686-5 and 686-4?
    • While both models typically feature smooth and consistent trigger pulls, some users may perceive slight differences based on personal preferences and individual firearm variations.
  3. 3. Can I use +P ammunition with the 686-5 and 686-4?
    • Yes, both models are designed to handle +P ammunition, but it's essential to refer to the manufacturer's recommendations and guidelines for optimal performance and safety.
  4. 4. Do the 686-5 and 686-4 come with adjustable sights?
    • Yes, most variants of both models come equipped with adjustable sights, allowing shooters to fine-tune their aiming for precise accuracy.
  5. 5. What maintenance regimen is recommended for the 686-5 and 686-4?
    • Regular cleaning and lubrication are crucial for maintaining the optimal performance and longevity of both models. Consult the owner's manual for detailed maintenance instructions.

Gun Specifications

Specifications Smith & Wesson 686-4 Smith & Wesson 686-5
Capacity 6 6
Gun Type Revolver Revolver
Action Single Single
Barrel Length 4" 6"

Recent Deals

Glock 17 Gen 5

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Glock 43x

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Guns.com

$529.99

Gun Descriptions

Glock 17 Gen 5

The G17 Gen5 features a no finger grooved, multiple backstrapped, rough textured frame with hundreds of miniature spikes which results in remarkable traction for extreme environments and gloved operators. The frame also features a smooth trigger, reversible mag release, and ambidextrous slide stop. The magazine comes with a floor plate which is extended at the front for faster magazine change, and a orange follower, while the flared mag-well makes it easier to funnel the magazine into the mag-well. Glock's nDLC finish provides a tougher, more durable protection against corrosion and scratching. The Glock Marksman barrel features a barrel rifling which delivers improved accuracy. his Glock Gen 5 model has fixed front and rear sights.

Glock 43x

The silver finished slide of the G43X combines its short and slim dimensions to the extended slim frame size of the G48. A perfectly balanced slim fit for nearly all hand sizes with a satisfying magazine capacity and high concealability. The magazine capacity of the slim 01 magazine of the G43X is 10 rounds. This model has Glock night sights. Specifications: Gun Case: Plastic