Cimarron Thunderer For Sale, Review, Price - $493.18 - In Stock

Cimarron Thunderer

GunCritic Score

Critic Rating

User Rating

16 Reviews



Used Price:


Sale Price:


Cimarron Thunderer Gun Stats

Cimarron Thunderer

Want to Sell Your Gun?

Get Instant Offer
To paraphrase the famed film director John Ford, "If this isn't the way the Old West sixguns were, it's the way they should have been!" The Thunderer, a full-sized Model P, peacemaker-style single-action revolver that was designed by Cimarron founder and president Mike B. Harvey and made on the Old Model (pre-1896) frame and "bullseye" ejector head. However, as a departure from the traditional peacemaker-style arm, this six-shooter utilizes the natty birds head grip, and is much like that carried by Val Kilmer's "Doc" Holliday in the 1993 hit Western, Tombstone. Cimarron's Thunderer is available in the 4 3/4-inch barrel or the 5 1/2-inch barrel, as well as a 3 1/2-inch barreled version, that makes for a superb carry single action. This well-balanced smokewagon is offered in Standard Blue finish with the color case hardened frame and hammer, a .45 Colt, .45 Colt/.45 ACP dual cylinder, .44 Special, .44-40, .38 Special/.357 Magnum. This Cimarron Thunderer β€˜is a daisy!’

Cimarron Thunderer For Sale

Cimarron Thunderer Specs

1 Brand

2 Category

Technical Data






Case Hardened

Gun Type




Barrel Length


Cimarron Thunderer Ballistics

Find Cimarron Thunderer For Sale Near Me

No Guns Available.

How much is a Cimarron Thunderer worth?

In 2022 a new or used Cimarron Thunderer value varies depending on supply and demand. In the last 12 months there is great demand for a Cimarron Thunderer and most handguns. The Price for a Cimarron Thunderer has increased in cost by $0.00 in 2022 compared to 2021.

Estimated New and Used Values for a Cimarron Thunderer Values are based on a basic model with no options or colors.

Condition Trade-In Private Party Dealer
New In box $380.50 $497.57 $585.38
Excellent $351.23 $468.30 $526.84
Very Good $321.96 $468.30 $526.84
Good $292.69 $439.04 $497.57
Fair $204.88 $380.50 $468.30
Poor $146.35 $292.69 N/A

Gun Value Conditions explained:

New in box - 100% condition in unopened box. Excellent - 95%+ condition with or without box.

Very Good - 90% - 95% condition (all parts/finish should be original).

Good - 80-90% condition (all parts/finish should be original).

Fair - 30% - 80% condition, parts, and finish may or may not be original. Must function properly and shoot.

Poor - under 30% condition. Firearm has severe wear and tear, does not function, or is damaged.

Guncritic Icon

Want To Sell Your Cimarron Thunderer?

Quick Cash Offer

  • We make you an quick cash offer online

  • We find the dealer that offers you the most money

  • Get cash for your gun or do a trade in

How We Compare to Selling It Yourself

We take all the hassle out of selling your gun.

Speed Icon

Save Time

Quick Cash Offer

Get your cash offer in minutes

Selling it Yourself

Can take months to sell your gun privately

Buyer Icon


Quick Cash Offer

Trusted retailers will pay you for your gun

Selling it Yourself

You don't know who you're selling to, or if they'll rip you off

Price Icon


Quick Cash Offer

I'ts totally free to get a cash offer on your gun

Selling it Yourself

It costs money to place ads to sell your gun, and it takes a lot of time

Diffuculty Icon


Quick Cash Offer

Easy online paperwork and registration process for your safe and legal payout

Selling it Yourself

You have to trust the buyer to pay you, and trust that you're following the law

Cimarron Thunderer Critic Reviews

Guncritic Icon

Nov 10, 2021

| Full review

Hickok45 (Greg Kinman)

Cimarron Thunderer Rate And Review

How would you like to rate Cimarron Thunderer?

Jul 18, 2019

Rating: 1/5


Steve M

Mar 15, 2019

Rating: 5/5



Feb 08, 2019

Rating: 5/5


Richard C

Jun 13, 2016

Rating: 5/5


Joe D

Jun 28, 2013

Rating: 5/5


Charles H

Feb 02, 2018

Rating: 4/5


Craig S

More reviews 6 of 16

Cimarron Thunderer Q & A

There are no questions related to Cimarron Thunderer


Cimarron Thunderer Problems

There are no problems related to Cimarron Thunderer


Related Products