Pietta Model 1858 New Army with Starter Kit

Pietta Model 1858 New Army with Starter Kit

Part Number: IK-216068

UPC: 0809579596699

GUNCRITICMETER

Positive: 0
Negative: 0

AUDIENCE SCORE

94
Positive: 67
Mixed: 18
Negative: 3

Part Number: IK-216068

UPC: 0809579596699

Price and Used Value
Retail Price: $319.00 Used Value: $207.00

How would you like to rate Pietta Model 1858 New Army with Starter Kit?

Post

Pietta Model 1858 New Army with Starter Kit Description

The Remington Model 1858 was one of the most powerful and rugged single-action revolvers of its day. Easily removable, replaceable cylinders made reloading extremely fast. The highly realistic Pietta Model 1858 New Army .44 Caliber Black Powder Revolver delivers the same power and durability as the original with its blued steel construction, polished brass trigger guard, octagonal barrel and walnut grips. Starter Kit includes: a nipple wrench, straight line capper, adjustable powder measure, powder flask, 30 lead round balls, 30 3mm-thick lubed wads and 30 10mm-thick lubed wads.

Pietta Model 1858 New Army with Starter Kit Specifications

Brand Pietta Model
Action Single Action
Caliber .44 Caliber
Capacity 6
Finish Blue/Brass
Sights Fixed Sights
Primary Uses
 
Shooting
Shooting

Pietta Model 1858 New Army with Starter Kit Videos

Pietta Model 1858 New Army with Starter Kit Pricing

Poor
Condition
$128
Excellent
Condition
$288
Used Gun
Fair Market Range $295 - $308
Fair Market Price $302
MSRP $319.99
New Gun

Pietta Model 1858 New Army with Starter Kit Q & A

There are no questions related to Pietta Model 1858 New Army with Starter Kit

Pietta Model 1858 New Army with Starter Kit User Reviews

Positive: 67 Mixed: 18 Negative: 3
  • 80

    Accurate cap& ball
    I have two of these revolvers both are very accurate with cap & ball or conversion cylinders. I did however upgrade the nipples, so the caps stayed on better.

    August 1, 2017
    450Nitro
  • 100

    Excellent Shootin' Iron
    The quality of the revolver is truly impressive; deep blue, no machine marks, and perfect fit of parts. But what really impressed me is the accuracy! With round ball over a felt wad, the revolver is shooting tight, consi...stent groups to point of aim at 25 yards. Right on par with my Smith Model 57. Also put some fun factor back into my range sessions, and makes them more relaxed. It's a bit like instant gratification from reloading at the range. Also draws a lot of interest from smokeless shooters and enhances the social aspect of range time. more

    May 29, 2016
    Endust
  • 100

    1858 44 cal.
    The 1858 was the first black powder revolver I bought from Cabela's.. It was on sale and I'm so glad I bought it. Its finish and function was excellent. It likes the 454 round balls and is very accurate to shoot. I recei...ved it quickly with no problems with shipping. I would buy again. more

    January 2, 2016
    TerryRoger
  • 100

    1858 Remington Love it!
    So glad I bought this.. Now if I could just find everything needed to enjoy shooting it. Finish is very nice, No mill marks or dings. Crisp action seems very solid and sure. Right out of the box..no polish or tuning need...ed. Got the starter kit with it. The .451 balls will cut a small ring when loading but next time I want to try the .454.Shoots very well and the #10 Remington caps work fine. I am using Black Powder 3FG and it caint be better. If you are wanting to shoot BP Revolvers.. This one is a keeper. I caught it on sale for less than you find a used one on the market. Thanks Cabela's.. more

    May 10, 2015
    TerryRoger
  • 100

    Pietta 1858
    A well made gun look's great and very fun to shoot!

    April 30, 2015
    Msb1278
  • 100

    Great BANG for your buck..
    I recently purchased the Pietta Model 1858 New Army .44 caliber revolver from Cabella's. I have been shooting black powder weapons for the past 45 years and this is by far the best replica I have ever owned or shot. The ...fit and finish is superb, the workmanship surpasses that of the old gunsmiths and this is an outstanding buy. If you have ever had the urge to shoot black powder revolvers, get this one. Also, be sure to get the spare cylinder for quick reloads. more

    April 22, 2015
    Blitzfike
  • 100

    Nice Gun and Kit
    Beautiful gun out of the box, excellent craftsmanship and a great replica of a great American Classic. Fun to shoot, mechanically sound. I also purchased a .45 LC conversion cylinder designed for shooting Cowboy Action l...oads, again performed flawlessly. The starter kit will provide you with everything you need to get started except the powder/caps. The powder horn is plastic but gets the job done. At some point you will need to purchase more wads, seals and lead balls once you have exhausted this supply. The lead balls are OK, they have the excess burrs on them from when they were casted. You can also buy quality round balls made by Hornady also sold from Cabela's. Overall a great set. more

    March 11, 2015
    JGM3
  • 80

    fun to shoot and open carry
    the only reason why I did not give 5 stars is the instructions from pietta and the ones from cabelas dont jive, for powder charge, I weighed my charge out on my RCBS scale to see if the included powder measure was on...i...t is not. so i weighed 32 grains of Pyrodex (P) and set the measure accordingly shoots well, I ordered Hornady .451 and .454 round balls, have not recieved 454's to try yet. It is fun too shoot, cleaning is easy, check out the video duelist1954 dose on you tube for disassembly and cleaning. My friend shot it today and he will be buying one, a good conversation piece,as I open carry it. I recommend this pistol, remember, pyrodex clean with 1 part water and 1 part vinegar more

    February 15, 2014
    PAdesparado
  • 100

    Well Crafted Shooter
    I have three Cabela's Pietta revolvers. All three are well fitted, well finished, and strong for replica BP revolvers. I have shot this gun many times with a cylinder full (allowing only a ball to barely seat) of Schuetz...en FFFg, it has held up fine. It shoots quite well for accuracy as well. I recommend it highly. more

    October 25, 2013
    JayGibson
  • 100

    Great value, great gun
    I was expecting quality and quick delivery and that is exactly what I got! The 1858 New Army .44 has a good weight and feel and is solidly built. The starter kit that came with it is doable as well. I will be placing fut...ure orders with Cabela's! more

    July 11, 2013
    Possumboy
  • 100

    1858 New Army .44 Black Powder
    The fit and finish is outstanding. Perfect gun, you won't be disappointed.

    June 27, 2013
    PhantomYooper
  • 80

    A good Revolver
    I like the Remington 1858. It is well-built and easy to maintain. This is definitely a way to shoot without having to pay outrageous prices for ammo.

    June 6, 2013
    dlwilson001
  • 100

    Top quality
    My only suggestion for improvement is with the Pietta instructions. All of their cap & ball revolvers are covered by this one manual. Different models are described with different terms, depending on what page you ar...e on. I thought I had researched this gun, but nowhere in the catalog or literature is this described as being a copy of a Remington model, yet there is an important instruction that refers to "Remington" without confirming that THIS one is a Remington . I had to go to the internet verify that. YouTube in particular has been most helpful. more

    April 28, 2013
    MACH37
  • 80

    Nice purchase
    Extremely happy with the pistol. The only thing that kept this from gettng 5 stars was the nipple wrench that came with the starter kit. Already had to modify it. It broke after the first use. The pistol is great!

    February 25, 2013
    phillyparot
  • 100

    great pistol
    my first cap and ball pistol. shot it four times love the gun and will buy others in the colection.i need more pratice cannot hit anything past ten foot

    February 26, 2013
    kneeshurt
  • 40

    Starter kit is worthless
    The Pietta pistol is excellent but the starter kit is worthless. The balls are less than .451 and poorly cast and the powder flask is made of cheap plastic. Save your money and purchase individual items.

    February 6, 2013
    Bobr110
  • 100

    Pleasantly surprised
    After almost 40 years since I last owned any cap and ball revolver, I decided to re-vist having one. I was amazed at the improvement in quality in the new Italian replicas. With the price of ammunition and components ris...ing, I'll still be able to enjoy target shooting at a fraction of the cost of my cartridge guns. Sure it's more work to shoot and clean but it'll help keep me occupied during retirement. The only thing is the Pietta manual suggest 15 grains of fff powder. The Cabelas manual states 30 grains. I'm using Cabelas recommendation to avoid a gap between the powder and ball. more

    January 28, 2013
    s0000000d
  • 100

    I Like
    Revolver is soli locks op tight but not so tight that changeing the cylinder is a problem.

    December 24, 2012
    clip1954
  • 100

    Pietta Model 1858 New Army
    I have wanted a black powder pistol for a long time. I saw this one in a sale catalog and had to "pull the trigger" and buy it. The quality of the gun is great and I would recommend this to anyone looking for a... nice revolver. more

    December 13, 2012
    Challenger440
  • 100

    Beautiful!
    Wow I can't beleive it less than a week to get here. It was securley packed and well oiled. I have not shot it yet but will next time on the range. Very impressed with the quality and overall feel of this gun. Plan to bu...y more in the future. more

    November 27, 2012
    rustycowboy
  • 100

    Accurate right out of the box.
    Great fun to shoot, bullseyes at 25 yards with 30 grains of powder .454 balls I have fired a couple of hundred rounds with out any incidents/misfires. I definetly reccomend, perfect for first time buyers.

    October 31, 2012
    chinabill
  • 100

    Fun Gun
    Pietta Model 1858 New Army .44 Caliber Revolver is very well made and has great balance. This is the first blackpowder gun I have fired and what fun and very accurate, at 10 yards I get a tighter group then I do with my ...9mm and I love the way the gun feels in my hand. more

    October 28, 2012
    LL7001
  • 100

    Cool to Own - Cool to Shoot
    Cool gun, well manufactured, a lot of fun o shoot. Not a fast shooter because loading takes some getting used to and practice, but the gun is fun and accurate,lots of noise and smoke if you use gun powder instead of Pyro...dex. Pyrodex is more reliable and not affected by humidity like gun powder is tho. more

    September 28, 2012
    kevin213DE
  • 100

    Black Powder Pistol
    Its been sometime since I fired a black powder gun, I always wanted one, and now I have my own. Its a very well made pistol, and I know I will enjoy firing it, this weekend. People get one of these, to enjoy the wild wes...t, of long ago. Happy trails to you!! more

    September 28, 2012
    Bustagut
  • 100

    Very nice!
    This is my first big venture back into black powder since my days in college. Recently have become interested in SASS type competition and thought that this would be a good way to get started. Must say that when this pis...tol arrived, I was quite impressed at the size and how substantial the Pietta felt in hand. This is by no means a small or lightweight gun! LOL! more

    September 24, 2012
    ReindeerII
  • 100

    Pietta Model 1858 New Army .44 Caliber Revolver
    Excellent workmanship on the pistol.

    July 25, 2012
    Sowerdough
  • 80

    Great gun for the price
    This gun was easy to load, but had a problem with the caps. #11 caps are in the starter kit but should have gotten #10 because the caps popped off after the first shot. Over all a lot of fun to shoot.

    July 23, 2012
    Rider45
  • 100

    1st time purchase of cap and ball pistol
    A well built pistol. The cylinder is easy to remove when time to reload. Inexpensive to shoot,compared to modern handguns.

    July 26, 2012
    4u2shooter
  • 100

    Great .44
    Only fired this once so far. A get acquainted shoot at 20 yds. Fired about 6 cylinders. Started hitting targets toward the end of the shoot. Not the guns fault. I haven't been shooting in 10 yrs. Next time bench rest and... proper targets to zero sights. I like this gun. more

    May 5, 2012
    BLuther
  • 100

    Nice
    Great piece for the money. Lot's of fun. Nice finnish! Been thinking of buying one for years and now am glad I finally did!

    March 29, 2012
    wohela
  • 100

    Cabelas saves the Union!
    Due to a promotion in my Civil War reenactment unit, I needed a side arm. I reserached all options and various dealers. The Remington 1858 was my choice and Pietta is, without question, the most popular replica available.... It has a long history of superior finish and performance. That, plus the great price at Cabela's, was all I needed to order mine.It and a spare cylinder, arrived on schedule and exceeded my best dreams. My friends who are active black powder shooters were particularly impressed by the fit and finish and general quality.When I take to the field this spring, my Remington 1858 will be at my side, except when I have it out to impress the spectators and Johnny Rebs! more

    March 26, 2012
    Veldcornet
  • 100

    Well worth the wait
    This revolver was back ordered when I bought it; Cabelas delivered it as was posted. This revolver is great! The fit and finish are outstanding, defects described such as poor fitting stocks, tool marks etc were not evid...ent on my revolver. The accuracy is right on the money. The finish is very dark, even and smooth. The biggest goodie is the trigger action. It breaks smoothly at a very acceptable pull. more

    February 16, 2012
    MountainWilliam
  • 80

    Fun Revolver
    On balance I think I should have bought the version with adjustable sights, but even so, I really enjoy shooting this revolver.Definitely worth the money.

    February 5, 2012
    RogerA400
  • 100

    Love the 1858 New Army Revolver
    I have plenty of other firearms but this was my first black powder gun. I'm having more fun at the range than with all my other guns. The quality and craftmanship are great. I'm really impressed with how amazingly accura...te it is. I can hit an average size pumpkin from a standing position at 50 yards 9 out of 10 shots. BTW, I bought a second one because it is such a great deal. more

    January 30, 2012
    GiddingsMan
  • 100

    The real deal
    Before I bought this pistol, I thought black powder guns were just a novelty. Turns out, these guns are well made firearms and when properly loaded, they are as good as any modern firearm. The 1858 New Army is a good sol...id pistol and works very well. Although not as powerfull as as some modern large bore handguns, you wouldn't want to find yourself on the wrong end of one. It has made shooting fun again. In the 5 months I have had it, I have fired just short of 1000 rounds with no problems. Great gun. more

    January 3, 2012
    Riverman778
  • 100

    dirty enjoyment
    this revolver is only for those that understand shooting blackpowder. and that is "cleaning it is no fun". but shooting it is a hoot. my son and i took it shooting and had a blast (pun intended). the first time... loading went a lot slower than the remainder of the loads, but we soon got the hang of it. i recommend watching some of the plentiful videos on the internet as schooling in loading. i can't complain about the starter kit either, it's helpful in getting you lined out on what is needed to enjoy shooting this well made pistol more

    January 6, 2012
    rustyblade
  • 100

    Just purchased
    The pistol arrived and it looks great. Well made, balance and handling is great. Picked up the extra cyclinder to make reloading easier. Haven't had a chance to shoot it yet, waiting for spring.

    January 7, 2012
    osmbob
  • 100

    Better than expected!
    Wow! From opening the box to shooting the gun, I was very pleased. The quality and workmanship of the revolver was much better than I expected. The gun looks much better than the price reflects. When I took it to the sho...oting range, I was shooting at a 2 inch red round dot at 25 yards. The very first shot out of the gun was 1/2" high from dead center. I don't save very many targets from the range, but I'm saving this one. If you have been thinking of getting a black powder revolver, you can't go wrong here. more

    January 3, 2012
    Gplus
  • 100

    an excellent choice!
    I ordered this for a friend who uses it for home protection as well as plinking and target shooting. it is easy to break down for cleaning and shoots well with round patched balls and 35 gr of pyrodex.

    January 5, 2012
    bubba12
  • 100

    Great Christmas Gift
    It was an early gift, but I have already shot this great replica- I didn't expect the accuracy and just plain enjoyment of shooting a black powder pistol. I let a friend shoot it and he has already purchased one and we h...ave enjoyed several days out plinking!!! more

    November 26, 2011
    Thornsteel
  • 60

    fun gun
    works fine, last's a long time.

    October 14, 2011
    epeelife
  • 100

    1858 starter kit
    Great gun, the kit is a little "eh" but it was worth the package deal in order to get the starting ammunition and wads. A must have for the black powder fans.

    July 9, 2011
    kdogcrusader
  • 100

    More accurate than expected!
    Finally got to shoot the pistol. It is more accurate than I expected. My LEO brother was impressed too as he shot 5 shots in a 1 inch group at 20 yds.My groups were more like 2".I got 2 extra cylinders, 45 colt conv...ersion and the Cheyenne holster, and Laramie drop belt. (The 45 colt is awesome.) Quality of bluing and finish is excellent, brass trigger guard is good, no sharp edges as others have noted. #10 caps fit perfect. #11 caps were loose. As others suggested Trip 7 FFFG powder really rocks.The starter kit is just that a starter kit. Some complain about the price, but top of the line items will really run up a bill. My only complaint on the kit is the flask is hard to load. A small funnel would have been nice. more

    June 20, 2011
    estex
  • 100

    My first Gun
    The gun shoots great, but the stater kit isn't worth much. A great purchase for my first gun.

    June 9, 2011
    czar84
  • 100

    1858 new army 44cal
    a very fine piece top of the line quility made weaponi hope to enjoy it for many years

    February 20, 2011
    aaron8698
  • 100

    Good Deal
    i havent shot it yet, but it is a solid well built, and very attractive gun, the gun is well worth the money.

    February 8, 2011
    beetle721
  • 100

    BETTER THAN I HOPED FOR!
    THE REVOLVER WAS A GEM, WELL MADE. SHOT TO THE POINT OF AIM. SPARE CYLINDER CAME IN HANDY WITH ALL THE SHOOTING I DID. THIS IS THE FIRST TIME I EVER SHOT BLACK POWDER, I'M HOOKED.

    February 3, 2011
    ITALIANSALAMI
  • 80

    Great Buy
    The fit and finish is very good and all components of the started kit are of excellant value. Seems to function well, however the true test will come at the range as soon as the weather breaks. Two manuals came with the ...revolver, the cabelas manual was informative and easy to understand. The manual from the manufacturer was a little more difficult. more

    February 4, 2011
    Bobobuck
  • 100

    Great Revolver I am hooked!!
    The 1858 New Army Revolver steal frame with an 8'' barrel is great! Cabela's did a great job with customer service and the shipping was fast. I now have an order in my cart that has a 1851 Navy U.S. Marshal .44 and anoth...er 1858 New Army Revolver .44 with a 5 1/2'' barrel and plus holsters and belts and lots of other stuff totaling over $1100.00. Thanks so much Cabela's for showing me something me and my wonderful wife can enjoy togather. U have a customer for life!! more

    January 25, 2011
    169DCavScout
  • 100

    black powder gun
    This gun appears to be a quality piece. I am very pleased with it. Great for shooting or display. Several people have remarked that they liked the appearance and again quality. Thanks

    January 27, 2011
    newsport
  • 100

    Black Powder Hand Gun
    For a first timer, this was a very good choice. It was very simple to load and it was a blast to fire. I would highly recommend this gun to start out with in any black powder shooting.

    December 30, 2010
    1992
  • 80

    BUD
    GUN IS WELL MADE. FRONT SIGHT IS A LITTLE OFF CENTER.I'M SATISFIED WITH IT. OVERALL IT'S A GOOD QUALITY FOR THE PRICE.

    September 4, 2010
    BUDDY1933
  • 100

    1858 44 BP
    Real nice shooter great point of aim point of impact and just a lot of fun to shoot.

    July 13, 2010
    Smokealot
  • 100

    ???
    Just what I wanted

    May 22, 2010
    jimbob40
  • 100

    1858 New Army
    Beautiful product.....very accurate!!!!! Used it right out of the box in the range 1/2 to 3/4 pattern on center at 50 yards. Worked flawless!!!!!

    April 19, 2010
    06Roadking
  • 100

    1858 remmie- Pietta 44 cal 8 inch barrel
    Right out of the box this remmie is beautiful, I have found no flaws in workmanship as others have described. Perhaps I just recieved the best one, I also ordered the spare cylinder slips right in not a problem, watch th...e loading lever as it will hold cylinder out until it is properly positioned. I shall use this as back up side arm to my TC hawken when hunting. Often the grizzly bear is dead on the run without knowing. This will give me the extra peace of mind. Shot groups 1.5 to 2 inch at 30 yds, use #11 caps.Shipping, Cabelas is outstanding not only do they have everything you need but shipping is very quick, I ordered and received in 4 days. Great job Cabelas. more

    April 20, 2010
    barkiller
  • 100

    Pietta made Remington New Army Revolver
    I own a genuine Remington New Model which I don't shoot for obvious reasons. The Cabela's version is made by Pietta in Italy and is a very well made replica - almost identical to the original. The starter kit includes ev...erything you need except powder, caps (use #10) and cleaning supplies. There is a very complete set of instructions if you've never shot a black powder gun before. more

    April 4, 2010
    Anonymous
  • 100

    A Fine Revolver
    I bought the 1858 Remington revolver the week after Christmas. In a little over a month, I've put probably a hundred rounds through it with no problems whatsoever. The fit and finish are excellent. All that was required ...was to wipe the protective oil from the surfaces, then it was ready to go. more

    January 27, 2010
    Notspart
  • 100

    Great gift!
    Gave to my hubs for Christmas, and he really liked it!!

    January 5, 2010
    Ewifey
  • 100

    1858 44cal. revolver
    Very nice fit and finish!!!!!!!!!!!

    December 27, 2009
    sre3
  • 100

    Excellent Pistol!!
    Excellent Pistol, fit and finish are great. Shoots very good.A real hoot.This may not be the most expensive pistol on the market, but well worth the money. Enjoy.

    September 4, 2009
    TXIntruder
  • 100

    1858 Army .44 Cal Revolver
    Great gun, lots of fun. Only drawback is cleaning but that's black powder!

    August 9, 2009
    Deutche
  • 80

    1858 new army .44
    i would really give this gun a 4.5 but its a 4 or a 5 so i gave it a 4. i was attracted to this pistol from clint eastwood movies and i also got to fire a black powder rifle at the shooting range one day. i was hooked ev...er since because i was firing a .22 high standard pistol and it wasn't fun compared to the preparation in loading of a black powder. the quality could be better on these pistols because the nipples were smashed, warped, and mushroomed sideways after firing 130 shots. the hammer tends to mushroom on the nipples which requires a little maintenance with a file and the reloading kit with the pistol is a good deal. 4.5 all the way and you can't go wrong! more

    March 23, 2009
    mcraigor
  • 80

    Very Nice Pistol
    This is my first 'owned' BP pistol; and I like it! Fit and finish are very nice; bluing is complete, deep and rich. Not perfect, but VG overall. I need to pull the triggerguard and polish out some tool-marks on the insid...e circumference - doesn't effect the operation (not finger-gouging) but it just isn't as pretty as the rest of the gun. Stocks fit very well and are a nice color out-of-the box; they've gotten better after rubbing out a little "accidental over-oiling" when cleaning. Shoots a little high and the trigger let-off is heavy (compared to my K-frame and N-frame S&W's), but that's what files are for! SA cocking force is on a par with both of my DA Smith's. more

    March 19, 2009
    DesertDawg
  • 100

    Great Product
    Took this out for the first time. I'm a new black powder shooter, so I had to read up on it and educate myself on how everything works. I had a great experience. We went out on a trap shoot in Missouri with the shotguns ...and I took this along to let the family and friends break it in with me, and we had a blast. It was a lot more accurate than I thought it would be! I could hit better with this than I could with my brother's $1,000 HK .45 semi-auto. There is no recoil, it kicks like a .22 pistol, but a loud smoky boom when it goes off though. I got the short barrel version of this, and I have been very happy with that decision. A couple of caps fell off when I shot once, but it was due to the cap loader I was using. When I loaded the caps by hand, never had an issue, very reliable. It cleaned up easily too. For the quality and the value, I would recommend this to anyone. more

    March 6, 2009
    Rafterman
  • 100

    smokegun
    Nice unit

    March 5, 2009
    revderek
  • 100

    1858 New Army
    I haven't had a chance to shoot my new Army yet but I was pleased of the overall quality of the gun. I feel its a great value for the price. The gun points like a dream.I got the starter kit with the gun and that was als...o quite nice. Although I plan to replace the plastic powder flask with a brass one before I start shooting.Great service from Cabela's also. more

    March 7, 2009
    Crowriver
  • 100

    Great revolver so far
    I received my 1858 yesterday via UPS. I can't say that I've had a chance to fire it yet, but upon examination, I can say that it is a beautiful piece. The finish is superb (no noticeable scratches or machine/tool marks),... the action functions smoothly, the tolerances seem very tight regarding cylinder/barrel alignment, and overall the revolver looks excellent--it would make a great display piece. more

    March 5, 2009
    Iheartoutdoors
  • 80

    1858 New Army .44 Caliber Revolver w/ Starter Kit
    Item was in stock and received within 5 days! First, let me say that I was very impressed with the fit and finish of the revolver. The front sight was very-slightly bent to the left but, hardly affects shot placement. It... will take some time to become comfortable using the sights as the rear sight is a simple groove in the top of the receiver and the front sight is a very thin, vertical blade. The lead balls that come in the Starter Kit are very inconsistent in their roundness and I achieved much better groups using Hornady .454 diameter .44 caliber lead balls (product #6070), which by the way, weigh approximately 140 grains. Best of three, 6-shot groups measured 2 1/4" (with one flyer), @ 25 yards using approximately 18.2 grains of Pyrodex P measured with one fill of a Lee Dipper - size 1.6cc but, this is my first outing with the gun and further load development will be necessary. A NOTE OF CAUTION: The nipples are set at a slight angle away from the centerline of the cylinder (tilted towards the outside of the cylinder). You MUST align the nipple wrench with the angle to obtain the correct purchase/torque or you will most likely damage or break your nipple wrench as I did! HINT: I put a very small dab of Super Lube grease on the threads, which makes removal much easier. I would not order the combo Gun w/Starter Kit again as the items in the kit are not top-of-the-line and most of them are not really necessary. The gun itself is currently available ON SALE. Regardless of the minor problems noted, I am very pleased with the gun, the price and the quick delivery and I will most likely order a different 1858 New Army model in the near future but, ONLY FROM CABELA'S! more

    February 1, 2009
    r527
  • 100

    Display Looks
    My first BP pistol. It looks like it should be on display. I'm glad I didn't get the brass model. It's a blast to shoot. I bought the target model and am impressed. It shoots more accurate than some cartridge pistols. It... really puts you back in time. more

    January 2, 2009
    torchmanner
  • 80

    Good Gun - Conversion Cylinders
    I really enjoy this gun and would recommend it to others. Lots of fun to load and shoot. Wish I knew where to get one of the conversion cyclinders for this gun.

    October 27, 2008
    Gene18
  • 100

    Old West .44 Caliber Rvolver
    I really enjoy my New .44 Cal black powder Revolver. My first Old West collectors item, I plan on trying it out when I go to Washington to vacation a few days with my son & grandkids.I also like to collect old black ...powder rifles, just for display and one of my hobbies. They sure look nice mounted on the wall, something to talk about and show off my collection of old anteques....Ralph more

    April 16, 2008
    Sidekickpete
  • 80

    Civil War revolver
    I bought the 1858 New Army .44 caliber revolver for an anniversary gift for my husband. I was told that it was one of the best guns for the money. My husband loves it. And he thinks I am just GREAT for getting it for him... as a gift. more

    April 10, 2008
    quiltinglady
  • 100

    Excellent
    This gun shot perfect out of the box. I shot 30 Rounds before cleaning. No jamming of the cylinder at all. Easy to load and easy to clean. Accurate gun for the cheap price. looking to buy another one soon.

    March 29, 2008
    Ziggy218
  • 100

    My Favorite Pistol
    As a collector and shooter of black powder revolvers I must say the 1858 New Army is by far my favorite pistol. The full frame design is far superior to the Colt style revolvers. It is much stronger and allows for quick ...cylinder swaps. On a good day I can get off 12 target shots in 8 seconds with this pistol and a spare cylinder. I have fired mine many times with over 50 grains of American Pioneer fffg with no problems and never a misfire with a pinched #11 magnum cap. It is very accurate with 35 to 40 grains of powder and a patched .451 swaged ball to 50 yards. If you're going to buy a black powder pistol make this one your first choice. You won't believe the quality of this replica for the incredible price. more

    February 19, 2008
    AnimalControl
  • 100

    great gun
    I have fired 100 rounds and have no problem with this gun.The sights could be better, but in general the gun is very good

    January 12, 2008
    peacefulbob
  • 60

    issues...
    I purchased this one a little over a year ago, it's a fun shooter. Shortly after I got it, I noticed that it needed to be pointed down to roll the cylinder. After a complete disassembly, I discovered the the spring on th... cylinder hand had broken, I ordered a replacement through Dixie Gun Works, and after a little "smithing" had it working beautifully again. Don't get me wrong, I get a hoot and a holler outta shootin' this beauty. BTW for a little more realism, ditch the pyrodex and load REAL black powder. I load wad over powder with well "greased" balls. gotta have your balls greased you know, says so in the video. YE HAWW!! more

    January 4, 2008
    DirtyBob
  • 100

    Great gun and fun to shoot
    I bought the 1858 New Army .44 Caliber Revolver with Starter Kit an used it the same day. I am very satisfied with the performance and recommend it. I will probably buy more black powder firearms from Cabela's soon!

    October 18, 2007
    mbradleykc
  • 100

    1858 new army .44 caliber revolver
    It's great,plan to teach my grandson to shoot this weapon in a couple of years.Itell everyone just how much I like it.

    October 15, 2007
    Anonymous
  • 100

    Verry nice product
    Great product I recomend it highly.

    September 22, 2007
    trigon
  • 100

    Great value
    I bought the blued version with walnet grip as a present for a brother, a retired 82 Airborne Army vet, along with a US Calvery holster, belt, bullet pouch, and spare cylinder. I also got a 45 LC conversion cylinder, whi...ch is all we've used so far at the range. I consider the weapon to be a work of high calibre industrial art. You could pay much more for much less beauty. The .44 1858 clicks on all levels- shooting, history, and artwork. more

    August 19, 2007
    MaRefugee
  • 100

    Excellent Weapon
    The '58 .44 is a beatiful weapon and I am extremely pleased. A real fine replica of an original.

    August 9, 2007
    pallida
  • 80

    Gun yes - starter kit no
    Since receiving the (Pietta) 1858 Remington New Army .44 revolver I have had the opportunity for two range sessions. The gun is reasonably well made and a pleasure to shoot. With a little practice and load develoment it ...has no trouble hitting the black at 25 yards. Switching from .451 to .454 round balls definitely improved accuracy to that of most modern guns. I have opted for over the powder wads rather than applying grease in front of the ball. At about 36 rounds per session I had little trouble with fouling except the center pin which is a long known issue with this design. CCI #10 caps stay put and work fine. Nobel #11 caps tend to fall off unless you pinch them first.The gun tends to develop a little rust quickly so I recommend a full disassembly, which is not difficult, when cleaning. A Google search will produce good disassembly and cleaning advice. I have been shooting black powder and have not yet tried Pyrodex. It may prove to be a bit easier to clean.If you have any black powder accessories on hand skip the starter kit. It contains a plastic flask with no dispensing release, just a rubber cap on the spout. The kit also contains less than a standard size package of balls and wads. Buy accessories "a la carte" and get a metal flask with the correct size (+/- 24 grains) measuring spout. A spare cylinder and an aftermarket external loader helps make it more pleasurable to shoot.This is my first black powder revolver and I look forward to adding an 1861 Colt Navy .36 as my next acquisition. more

    April 18, 2007
    Liketomakesmoke
  • 80

    Nice revolver for the money
    I am satisfied with the revolver and starter kit. The finish quality is a little less than I expected, but the revolver is solid and seems to be well machined. My only complaint is the couple of burrs on the trigger and ...guard, and the caps were a difficult size to find in my area. more

    November 21, 2006
    MountainHiker
  • 80

    black powder revolver
    this a nice pistol for muzzle loader season,it shoots nice and it loads easaly than the rifle. It looks like the exact pistol used in the movie THE OUTLAW JOSEY WHALES Staring CLINT EASTWOOD.

    November 14, 2006
    CLICK
  • 80

    Great cowboy action gun
    If you're like me, when you watch one of Clint Eastwoods westerns, you can't wait to go to the range to try out your cowboy action guns.

    November 17, 2006
    Vladimire
  • 100

    First Blackpowder Firearm
    Even though I have been shooting nearly 40 years, every time I ended up with a blackpowder firearm through a trade I would move it along without ever firing it. On a whim, I decided to try out blackpowder and with the st...arter kit this seemed to be a great bargain. Well, the quality of the firearm, the enclosed documentation and the starter kit made my first blackpowder outing so enjoyable I now have three blackpowder revolvers and enjoy them at every opportunity.Thank you Cabela's for offering this excellent product. more

    November 12, 2006
    CraigC
  • 80

    Great Place to Start!
    The pistol is great. The pistol is a great shooter. Its a new gun, so the hammer is a little stiff. But the trigger is fine as is. Make sure you read the manual and use #10 caps.

    October 29, 2006
    Cyrus

Pietta Model 1858 New Army with Starter Kit Critic Reviews