Springfield XD-S Review

Kerith Cooper

|

February 9, 2024

|

0 comment

As a concealed carry enthusiast and a critic who takes pride on testing products thoroughly from the source, I couldn’t wait to get my hands on Springfield XD-S. It is a gun that has been shrouded in both hype and skepticism because of its wild claims to deliver power with portability. So, after spending a lot of time with the XD-S I’m ready to tell about my impressions from this compact powerhouse.

Springfield XD-S

Springfield XD-S Specifications

  • Caliber: 9mm, .40 S&W, .45 ACP
  • Barrel Length: 3.3 inches
  • Overall Length: 6.3 inches
  • Weight: 23 oz (empty)
  • Capacity: Varies by caliber (7+1 for 9mm, 6+1 for .40 S&W, 5+1 for .45 ACP, with extended options available)
  • Frame: Polymer
  • Slide: Forged steel
  • Safety: Grip and trigger
  • Sights: Fiber optic front, dovetail rear
  • Grip: Textured

First Impressions

As soon as I unboxed the Springfield XD-S, what caught my eye was its sturdy construction and detailing. It’s small, yes but it is substantial in the hand—a balance that can be difficult to achieve for concealed carry firearms. The texture of the grip offered a good feel thus providing for secure handling that was necessary since it was intended to be carried and possibly used under stress.

Hand gripping a black Springfield XD-S pistol over a case with spare magazines
Person aiming a Springfield XD-S pistol at a target in an indoor shooting rang

Springfield XD-S Performance

The XD-S did well at the range. The accuracy was quite good for a small firearm, showing tight groups at typical self-defense ranges. The recoil was controllable, partly due to the ergonomic design and textured grip that enabled one to stay on target for follow-up shots.

The XD-S has been in use for months and it is reliability that can be reported with no malfunction even after hundreds of rounds. This reliability, accompanied by small size and weight makes it a perfect candidate for concealed carry.

Concealability and Comfort

One of the most important features that would attract a potential buyer is its concealability. It is small enough to fit comfortably inside the waistband or in ankle holster all day long. I have tried several holsters and discovered that the XD-S adapts well to different carry positions, retaining a low profile without sacrificing concealability.

Close-up of the grip and trigger section of a Springfield XD-S handgun
Person firing a Springfield XD-S handgun with muzzle flash visible

Maintenance and Durability

The XD-S is easy to maintain. The disassembly and re-assembling is easy enough to promote regular cleaning, which, of course, should be a requirement for any carry handgun. Even after extensive use, the XD-S looks and functions as it did on day one indicating its toughness of construction.

Things I Love About the Springfield XD-S

  • Compact Yet Powerful: The Springfield XD-S is the epitome of “good things come in small packages.” It’s compact enough for concealed carry without compromising on the firepower, which is a big win for me.
  • Ergonomic Design: Holding the XD-S feels like it was made for my hand. The grip texture, balance, and overall ergonomics make it comfortable to shoot, even during long range sessions.
  • Safety Features: I appreciate the peace of mind the grip safety and trigger safety provide. It’s reassuring to know that the firearm has these additional safety measures without complicating its operation.
  • Accuracy: Despite its size, the XD-S is remarkably accurate. The fiber optic front sight really helps in acquiring targets quickly and maintaining accuracy, which is impressive for a compact firearm.
  • Build Quality: It feels solid. From the slide to the frame, everything about the XD-S screams durability. It’s a gun that I trust to withstand the rigors of daily carry and frequent use.
Hands loading a magazine into a Springfield XD-S handgun

Things I Don’t Like

  • Trigger Feel: Initially, the trigger felt a bit gritty to me. Though it has smoothed out over time and with use, it was something that I noticed right away and took some getting used to.
  • Capacity: While I understand the trade-offs for a compact design, I do wish the capacity was a bit higher, especially for the .45 ACP version. Having to choose between size and capacity is always a tough call.
  • Price Point: While you get what you pay for in terms of quality and reliability, the XD-S is on the pricier side compared to some other options in the compact market. It’s worth it, but still a consideration.
  • Holster Options: Finding the perfect holster took some trial and error. The XD-S can be a bit picky with holsters, and I went through a few before finding one that offered the right fit and comfort for everyday carry.

Overall, my experience with the Springfield XD-S has been overwhelmingly positive. It’s a reliable, accurate, and comfortable firearm for concealed carry. While there are a few aspects that aren’t perfect, the pros far outweigh the cons, making it a favored choice in my collection.

My Personal Maintenance Routine

Being a proud owner and daily carrier of the Springfield XD-S, I’ve developed an effective maintenance regime that guarantees my weapon is always in perfect condition, useful when needed. Here’s my personal maintenance routine:

Disassembled Springfield XD-S handgun with slide, barrel, and recoil spring

Weekly Checks
Even if I haven’t fired it, I perform a weekly safety check and quick clean:

  • Safety Check: Ensure the firearm is unloaded.
  • Visual Inspection: Check for any visible damage or unusual wear.
  • Quick Clean: Wipe down the exterior with a microfiber cloth and apply a light oil layer to prevent rust.

Post-Range Cleaning
After every range visit, a thorough cleaning is a must:

  • Disassembly: Field strip the XD-S according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
  • Barrel Cleaning: Use a bore brush and solvent to clean the barrel, followed by patches until they come out clean. A light coating of gun oil finishes the job.
  • Slide and Frame: Clean the slide, paying special attention to the breech face and extractor. Wipe down the frame and its components, removing any buildup.
  • Lubrication: Apply gun oil to moving parts, focusing on slide rails and any areas of metal-to-metal contact.
  • Reassembly and Function Check: After reassembling, I perform a function check to ensure everything works as intended.
Springfield XD-S pistol partially disassembled with components laid out on a textured surface

Monthly Maintenance
Once a month, I take a bit more time to inspect and maintain the XD-S:

  • Detailed Inspection: Check for any signs of unusual wear or potential issues.
  • Magazine Maintenance: Disassemble, clean, and inspect magazines to ensure reliable feeding.
  • Holster and Carry Gear Inspection: Clean and inspect my holster and carry gear for any wear or damage that could affect concealment or draw speed.

Seasonal Adjustments

  • Environmental Adjustments: Depending on the season, I may adjust the lubrication slightly. Lighter oils for cold weather and slightly heavier for hot, dusty conditions.
  • Carry Position Adjustments: Sometimes, seasonal clothing changes necessitate adjustments in carry position or holster selection.

Annual Professional Inspection
Once a year, I take my XD-S to a certified gunsmith for a professional inspection. This helps catch any issues I might have missed and ensures the firearm’s longevity and reliability.

Storage
When not in use, I store my XD-S in a dry, secure place. I use silica gel packets in my safe to control moisture and prevent rust.

This maintenance routine has served me well, keeping my Springfield XD-S in excellent condition and ensuring it’s always ready when needed. The key to firearm reliability is regular, meticulous care, and I take pride in maintaining my XD-S to the highest standards.

Springfield XD-S Performance Evaluation: My Expert Ratings and Insights

AspectReview SummaryScore
AccuracyThe Springfield XD-S exhibits impressive accuracy for a compact firearm, especially at close ranges.9/10
ReliabilityKnown for its dependable performance, the XD-S handles various ammunition types without issue.9/10
VersatilitySuitable for concealed carry, home defense, and range shooting, but limited by its compact size.7/10
CustomizationOffers a decent range of aftermarket support for sights, grips, and magazines, though somewhat limited.7/10
ErgonomicsDesigned for comfort and control, the XD-S is praised for its grip and ease of use.8/10
ValueOffers solid quality and performance for the price, though considered premium compared to some rivals.8/10
OverallThe Springfield XD-S is a reliable, accurate, and ergonomic choice for those seeking a compact pistol.8/10
Close-up of a Springfield XD-S pistol grip and trigger

Final Thoughts

The Springfield XD-S has lived up to and, in some ways, exceeded my expectations. It offers a compelling combination of concealability, power, and reliability, making it an excellent choice for anyone in the market for a concealed carry firearm. While it’s not without its compromises—namely capacity and an initially gritty trigger—the benefits far outweigh these minor drawbacks. For those considering a compact pistol, the XD-S deserves a close look. It’s a reliable, powerful, and comfortable carry weapon that has earned its place in my regular rotation.

FAQs

1. What calibers is the Springfield XD-S available in?
The XD-S is available in 9mm, .40 S&W, and .45 ACP, catering to different preferences for caliber performance and recoil.

2. How many rounds can the Springfield XD-S hold?
Capacity varies by caliber:

  • 9mm versions typically hold 7 rounds in the standard magazine and 9 with an extended magazine.
  • .40 S&W versions hold 6 rounds standard, 7 with an extended magazine.
  • .45 ACP versions carry 5 rounds standard, 7 with an extended magazine.

3. Is the Springfield XD-S suitable for concealed carry?
Yes, its compact design, lightweight, and slim profile make it an excellent choice for concealed carry without compromising on firepower.

4. What safety features does the Springfield XD-S have?
It includes a grip safety and trigger safety. Some models also feature a manual thumb safety, enhancing secure carry and operation.

5. How accurate is the Springfield XD-S?
The XD-S is known for its accuracy, thanks to its ergonomic design and fiber optic front sight which aid in quick and precise target acquisition, even in compact models.

6. Can the Springfield XD-S be customized?
Yes, it supports various aftermarket customizations including sights, triggers, grips, and magazine extensions, allowing owners to tailor it to their preferences.

7. How does the Springfield XD-S compare to other compact pistols?
The XD-S is competitive in the compact pistol market, offering a balance of concealability, firepower, and safety features that make it a favored choice among many concealed carriers.

8. Is the Springfield XD-S difficult to maintain?
No, its design allows for easy disassembly and maintenance without special tools, making it user-friendly for regular cleaning and care.

9. What makes the Springfield XD-S stand out from its competitors?
Its combination of ergonomic design, reliable performance, and integrated safety features, along with Springfield’s reputation for quality, make it stand out in the crowded compact firearm market.

10. Are there any common issues with the Springfield XD-S?
The XD-S is generally regarded as a reliable pistol. However, some users initially find the trigger pull a bit gritty, though this often improves with use. Additionally, while its capacity is sufficient for a compact firearm, those used to larger magazines may wish for more rounds.

You have chosen a dependable partner who manages power, accuracy and portability in one package that few can match. Regardless of whether you are a freshman or an experienced carrier, the XD-S will not only meet but also surpass your expectations in every situation that may occur.

avatar

Kerith Cooper

Author

read more about Kerith Cooper

Comment

Latest Post
post-thumb
Sarsilmaz SR 38 Review
A black Sarsilmaz SR 38 revolver with a matte finish and ergonomic grip on a...

June 11, 2024

post-thumb
Daniel Defense H9 Review
Discover the Daniel Defense H9 in 9mm Luger, a semi-auto with a 4.5″ cold hammer-forged...

March 4, 2024

post-thumb
Glock 21 Review
Experience the power of the Glock 21 in .45 ACP, featuring a 13-round capacity, 4.60″...

March 4, 2024

post-thumb
Ruger 5.7 Review
Meet the Ruger 5.7, chambered in 5.7x28mm, offering a high capacity of 20+1 rounds. It...

March 4, 2024

post-thumb
Ruger Security-9 Review
Explore the Ruger Security-9, a 9mm Luger with a 4″ barrel and a 15+1 capacity,...

March 4, 2024

Category

Weekly Newsletter

Do you want to get notified when a new article is added to Guncritic? Sign up for our newsletter and you'll be among the first to find out about new articles and reviews.

    By subscribing, you agree with Guncritic Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.